Stop Pretending You’re Not Scared (And Why That’s the First Step to Being Free)

Are you exhausted by the performance of being ‘okay’? Explore a journey from the ‘silent, gilded prison’ of fear-based living to the freedom of a Spirit-led identity. Discover how to…

Let’s be honest about the secret we usually only whisper: most of us are vibrating with a bone-deep, chronic exhaustion. We aren’t just tired; we are terrified. We’ve spent years “behavior-modifying” ourselves until we look the part of the “good Christian”. Nodding with approval in small groups while our internal world feels like the high-pitched static of an old television left on a dead channel.

For twenty-five years, I lived like God had given up on me. I wasn’t just empty; I was a shell. I was a shell autopiloting through destructive patterns I had practiced my whole adult life, building a “masterpiece” life that felt as hollow as a stage prop. From the sidewalk, it looked stable, respectable, even enviable. But inside? It was a silent, gilded prison. I wore the mask so long that the plastic began to feel like skin. I’ve always thought Psalm 32:3 captures that feeling of physical rot: “When I kept silent, my bones wasted away…” I didn’t just feel guilty; my joints literally ached from the weight of the performance.

The Architecture of the Mask

Fear isn’t an abstract concept; it’s a re-wiring. In my life, it started with the cold, metallic realization that I didn’t belong. Being adopted meant I had a hard time identifying with my family members. I often felt like a misfit growing up which created a void I tried to plug with my own brand of “manufactured certainty.”

We live in an era of global instability where warfare, political polarization, and economic volatility have fundamentally altered our emotional baseline. But the real horror isn’t just “out there.” It’s the internal architecture of fear that keeps us trapped in a false self.  
When the world feels like a horror to be survived rather than a mystery to be explored, our nervous systems snap. We retreat into rigid silos: “good guys” vs. “bad guys.” This isn’t a lack of character; it’s a neurobiological hijack. Beneath our skin, the amygdala screams, silencing the part of the brain meant for empathy. You cannot willpower your way out of a survival reflex.

But there is a counter-reflex. Romans 8:15 tells us we didn’t receive a spirit of bondage to fall back into fear, but a Spirit of adoption. My healing began not when I “fixed” my toxic behavior, but when I accepted that my status as an insider in God’s family was a gift that fear couldn’t touch.

The Empire of Control vs. The Kingdom of Love

We are currently drowning in a global surge of powerlessness. This feeling fuels the “Empire” mindset. The Empire relies on coercion and manufactured certainty. It justifies its greed through stories of “divine purpose,” portraying its violence as the only barrier to chaos. It creates a “homicidal mechanism” where perceived safety is built on the execution of others rather than forgiveness.  

Jesus offered a radical subversion: Self-emptying love. While the Empire asks, “How do I protect my borders?”, the Kingdom asks, “How does Love liberate me to serve my neighbor?” 1 John 4:18 is the tactical strike here: “Perfect love drives out fear.” If fear is about punishment, then Love is the absence of the courtroom. When the threat of punishment dies, the Empire loses its power to command you.

Unburdening the Parts

Modern psychology confirms that our current fears are often triggers for pain learned in childhood. Global instability activates the “inner child’s” unresolved trauma, making our adult reactions disproportionate and defensive. We check out, we dissociate, or we “numb” ourselves to escape the cold ice of fear.  

I used drugs and sex to numb the lingering shame of my double life. I was “autopiloting” through patterns I truly hated, but couldn’t stop.  

To fully heal, we have to go back to the origin of the fear. Psychologists suggest the human psyche is composed of “parts”. An Angry Part, a Fearful Part, a Procrastinating Part, each trying to protect us in its own way.  They aren’t villains; they are exhausted guards.

The goal isn’t to kill these parts. It’s to unburden them. When we rely on God to guide us and provide our identity, we can turn toward our fear of unknowing with curiosity instead of a gavel, the “Performer” can finally set down the mask. In the presence of the Holy Spirit, the static stops. The guards can go home.

The Miracle and the Walk

My “listening point” came in the wreckage of a personal implosion. I cried out to a God I hoped was more than a Sunday school story. In my truly broken state, the shift was instant. A switch flipped. In that light, I saw that the “me” I had spent thirty years polishing was a fake.

“The old has gone, the new has come!” (2 Cor 5:17). But let’s be real: The miracle, as real as it was, lasts a moment; the walk is a marathon. When the tears dried, I was still in the same living room with the same cravings and the same triggers. The sovereignty of a regenerated spirit is found in it’s constant slow crawl forward. It is the daily, gritty practice of retraining a brain that learned to survive in a war zone to finally rest in a garden.

The Microcosm of Action

You don’t have to solve global warfare. You just have to be kind to the person standing right in front of you.

It sounds small, but checking on a neighbor or grabbing a coffee for a coworker actually does something wild to our brains. It triggers ‘mirror neurons’ that help us bond and literally turns down the volume on our brain’s stress response. These aren’t just ‘nice gestures’, they are the smartest ways to reinvest your energy.

At the end of the day, every big move we make comes down to a choice between fear or love. Fear keeps us small and isolated; love builds the kind of connection that actually lasts. So, take a second and look in the mirror: What mask are you wearing today because you’re afraid of being seen?

Call it out. Own it. Then, just let it go. You haven’t missed your chance. You’re right on time.

Comments

One response

  1. BETH PETERSEN Avatar
    BETH PETERSEN

Leave a Reply to BETH PETERSEN Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.